Since the rise of prestige television in the 1990s, the annals of history have often been mined for captivating modern narratives. Demand for historical drama has never been in short supply, and while highbrow shows set in the Victorian Era or period crime thrillers have remained popular, few subgenres capture the imagination quite like the blood and eroticism of sword-and-sandals epics. As it did so frequently in the years surrounding the turn of the century, HBO set the benchmark for that style of television in the early 2000s.
The American-British historical drama Rome first released in 2005, and ran for just two seasons before coming to an end in 2007. Driven by a critically-acclaimed ensemble cast that featured top stars like Kerry Condon, Ciarán Hinds, Ray Stevenson, Tobias Menzies, and Kevin McKidd, Rome won four Emmy Awards (on eight total nominations) in its first season, and another three in its second season. The pieces were all in place for an all-time great show, and it’s well worth revisiting in rebooted fashion in the modern streaming era.
HBO’s ‘Rome’ Ended Much Earlier Than Planned
Rome was set in the first century B.C., just as Rome was transitioning from a republic to the dominant empire we now know it as. It featured a sprawling cast that blended real historical figures with fictional ones, with their lives and character arcs wrapped around key events from the time period. Some artistic license was taken as far as timeliness and accuracy are concerned, but Rome was neither intended to be nor advertised as a historically accurate depiction of the time period, even if it did borrow from real-world events and personas.
Unfortunately, despite all the acclaim and successful ratings, Rome was canceled after just two seasons due to its astronomical cost. The show is now infamous for its dizzyingly high budget, which was only possible due to a co-production between HBO and the BBC. At an average around $10 million per episode, it’s one of the most expensive TV shows in history. The ratings did decline in the second season despite consistently positive critical reception, and when the BBC withdrew from the production, the show was forced to end.
The original plan for Rome was a five-season arc that would have spanned decades and continue to expand the cast and scope of the series. It was intended to encompass events in Rome itself, Egypt, and reportedly even Palestine as it related to the rise of Jesus Christ. However, the unsustainable costs made it simply too ambitious a plan, and the series ended unceremoniously after two seasons, with elements from the third and fourth seasons folded into the second.
The Timeless Appeal of Sword-And-Sandal Drama Means a ‘Rome’ Reboot Could Work
The central concept behind Rome was excellent, and HBO and the BBC had a bona fide hit on their hands if not for the sky-high costs. The balance between blood, lust, political maneuvering, and epic battles simply never goes out of style, as Game of Thrones proved for HBO a decade later. The appeal of sword-and-sandal shows specifically has never wavered, with the greatest recent examples being Starz’s Spartacus and its spinoff House of Ashur.
Revisiting Rome could be a great play if it could be executed at a lower cost, which is certainly possible given the $2 million-$5 million price tags of Spartacus episodes. The show has gained some cult classic appeal as new viewers have discovered it on alternative streaming services like Netflix, and with two seasons of excellent material to draw on, it could be relatively easy to dive back into that world from a writing standpoint. The cast would be different, of course, but the concept of a semi-historical epic war drama centered around Rome at the turn of the millennium could be a major winner if someone runs with it.
‘Rome’ Should Return as an Anthology
The best format for a reboot may in fact be an anthology as opposed to a serialized overarching narrative. The original five-season plan for Rome would have nearly operated in that fashion anyway, as it was set to bounce around different major events within the empire across decades. The anthology could be built out across entire seasons, 2-3-episode arcs, or even to tell a separate story across each episode. Leaning harder into that setup would allow for a much more diverse array of storytelling, and explore more corners of the world at that time without having to tether the narrative to a series of consistent protagonists.
An anthology setting would also naturally lend itself to a larger, more inclusive cast. With so many more people and nations to cover within the context of the Roman Empire, the show could be built around guest stars and cameos, with a new star at the center of each new story (think Netflix’s Black Mirror). That could create even more stand-alone appeal in addition to the built-in historical drama audience. An anthology may not be quite so heavy on slow-burn political scheming as the original Rome was, but the trade-off would be an exciting update on the core concept that covers the development of the Roman Empire.
